More
After a crash, you trust that the other driver’s insurance will take care of your injuries. Then reality sets in: the coverage barely makes a dent in your growing medical bills or lost income. It’s frustrating and feels deeply unfair.
When another driver’s insurance falls short, you may still have options through your own policy and other available coverage. A skilled car accident attorney can identify these options, interpret complex policy language, and pursue full financial recovery from every available source.
Contact Finz & Finz, P.C. at 855-TOP-FIRM to speak with a team that understands how to handle underinsured driver claims in New York. A brief consultation can give you a clearer picture of your next steps and the coverage that may still be available to you.
Key Takeaways About Car Accidents with Underinsured Drivers
- Underinsured motorist coverage from your own policy may bridge the gap when the at-fault driver’s insurance falls short of your damages.
- New York requires minimum liability coverage of only $25,000 per person, which rarely covers serious injuries from modern car accidents.
- Multiple insurance policies might provide coverage for your injuries, including your own UIM coverage, health insurance, and household members’ policies.
- Filing deadlines and notice requirements vary between insurance companies, making immediate legal action necessary to preserve all compensation sources.
- Your right to compensation extends beyond the at-fault driver’s inadequate policy limits through various legal avenues.
Underinsured Motorist Coverage Explained for New York Drivers
New York Insurance Law requires insurers to offer underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage, though drivers may decline it in writing. This coverage activates when the at-fault driver’s liability insurance cannot fully compensate your damages. Your UIM coverage essentially steps into the shoes of the negligent driver, providing additional compensation up to your policy limits.
The difference between uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage confuses many accident victims. Uninsured coverage applies when the at-fault driver has no insurance at all. Underinsured coverage applies when they have insurance, but it’s insufficient for your damages.
Understanding Coverage Limits and Stacking Rules in New York
Your underinsured motorist, or Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (SUM), coverage usually matches your bodily injury liability limits unless you select different amounts.
Under New York law, you cannot “stack” SUM coverage for multiple vehicles insured under the same policy. In other words, you cannot combine the coverage limits of two or more vehicles on one policy to increase the total compensation available for a single accident.
In certain situations, however, more than one insurance policy may apply. For example, you might also be covered under a household member’s separate policy. While this can provide access to additional recovery, each policy applies independently, and the highest single policy limit ultimately sets the cap on what you can receive.
Determining your coverage requires careful policy review since many include anti-stacking clauses and complex coordination provisions. Factors that can affect your underinsured motorist claim include:
- Whether your SUM endorsement offers “add-on” coverage or “difference in limits” coverage
- The applicable policy limits and deductibles
- Coverage available under other household policies
- How benefits are coordinated among multiple insurers
These distinctions can have a major effect on the total compensation available. Legal guidance is often critical, since insurers rarely explain potential overlapping coverage that could increase what they owe.
Common Scenarios with Underinsured Drivers
Drivers with minimum coverage often cause severe accidents because they are frequently younger, less experienced, or facing financial challenges.
A driver carrying New York’s minimum $25,000 bodily injury coverage might total your vehicle and send you to the hospital. Your medical bills alone from surgery at Mount Sinai or NYU Langone quickly exceed their entire policy limit.
Commercial vehicles sometimes carry surprisingly low insurance despite their potential for catastrophic damage. Delivery drivers, rideshare operators, and small contractors may carry minimal coverage that doesn’t reflect their vehicles’ destructive capacity.
When these underinsured commercial drivers cause accidents on the Belt Parkway or Long Island Expressway, victims face massive uncovered losses.
How Hit-and-Run Accidents Affect Your Insurance Claim in New York
Hit-and-run accidents present unique challenges for recovering compensation, as the fleeing driver’s insurance remains unknown. Your uninsured motorist coverage typically applies to hit-and-run accidents, but insurers impose strict requirements. Physical contact with the fleeing vehicle must occur, and you must report the accident to police within 24 hours.
These technical requirements trap unwary victims who don’t immediately understand their importance. Insurance companies deny coverage for hit-and-run claims that don’t perfectly comply with policy conditions. Immediate legal consultation helps preserve your rights when the at-fault driver disappears.
Filing an Underinsured Motorist Claim with Your Own Insurance Company
Pursuing an underinsured motorist claim transforms your insurance company from protector to adversary. They assign adjusters and lawyers to minimize their payout, using tactics identical to those employed against other companies’ policyholders. This adversarial relationship surprises accident victims who expect their own insurer to treat them fairly.
Your insurance company demands extensive documentation proving both liability and damages exceeding the at-fault driver’s coverage. They scrutinize medical records, challenge treatment necessity, and dispute injury causation. Meeting their documentation demands while recovering from serious injuries becomes nearly impossible without legal assistance.
Deadlines and Notice Requirements for Underinsured Motorist Claims
Insurance policies contain strict notice requirements that vary between companies and coverage types. Some policies require written notice within 30 days of discovering the at-fault driver’s coverage inadequacy. Missing these deadlines may eliminate your right to underinsured motorist benefits regardless of injury severity.
The timeline for underinsured motorist claims differs from standard liability claims against the at-fault driver. Your claim against the negligent driver must resolve before pursuing UIM benefits. This sequencing creates delays that financially stress accident victims awaiting compensation.
Other Compensation Options After an Underinsured Driver Accident
Beyond underinsured motorist coverage, several additional sources might provide compensation for accident injuries. Health insurance covers medical expenses, though they’ll seek reimbursement from any accident settlement you receive. Disability insurance may replace lost wages if injuries prevent you from working.
The at-fault driver’s personal assets become relevant when insurance coverage falls short of your damages. While most underinsured drivers lack significant assets, some have property, savings, or future earning potential worth pursuing. Our attorneys investigate defendants’ financial situations to identify recoverable assets beyond insurance.
Employer Liability and Vicarious Responsibility
Accidents involving drivers working at the time of collision open additional compensation avenues through employer liability. New York’s vicarious liability doctrine holds employers responsible for employees’ negligent acts during work duties. This principle applies whether the driver was delivering packages through Queens or commuting between job sites on Long Island.
Commercial insurance policies often provide higher coverage limits than personal auto policies. Identifying employer-employee relationships requires investigation into the driver’s activities at collision time. Evidence of work-related driving transforms inadequate personal coverage into potentially substantial commercial claims.
How Damages Are Calculated When Insurance Coverage Is Limited
Accurate damage calculation becomes paramount when dealing with limited insurance coverage. Medical expenses include not just current bills but future treatment needs projected by medical professionals. Lost wages encompass both missed work and diminished earning capacity from permanent injuries.
Non-economic damages for pain and suffering, and lost enjoyment of life often exceed economic losses in serious accidents. New York law recognizes these intangible losses as legitimate damages requiring compensation. Insurance companies minimize these damages, arguing they’re subjective and unverifiable despite their real impact.
How to Maximize Recovery from Multiple Insurance Sources
Strategic claim sequencing maximizes total recovery when multiple insurance sources exist. Factors affecting the order of pursuing different coverage sources include:
- Policy language regarding primary versus excess coverage
- Subrogation rights between different insurers
- Settlement conditions that might affect other claims
- Statutory requirements for accessing certain benefits
This complex choreography requires experienced legal guidance to avoid missteps that reduce total compensation. Insurance companies exploit procedural errors to deny coverage or reduce payouts.
Protecting Your Rights After an Underinsured Driver Accident
Document everything related to your accident and injuries, creating a paper trail that supports maximum compensation. Photograph vehicle damage, obtain witness statements, and maintain detailed medical records. This evidence becomes vital when pursuing multiple insurance claims with different companies.
Avoid giving recorded statements to any insurance company unless advised by your attorney. Insurance adjusters use these statements to minimize claims, twisting your words to suggest lesser injuries or partial fault. Even your own insurance company’s adjuster works against your interests in underinsured motorist claims.
Medical Treatment Tips After an Underinsured Driver Accident
Consistent medical treatment demonstrates injury severity to skeptical insurance adjusters. Following your doctor’s treatment recommendations, attending all appointments, and completing prescribed therapy strengthens your claim. Gaps in treatment give insurance companies ammunition to argue your injuries aren’t serious.
Some medical providers work on liens, providing treatment now with payment from your eventual settlement. This arrangement allows necessary treatment even when insurance coverage gaps leave you without immediate payment sources. Our car accident attorneys maintain relationships with quality medical providers who understand accident cases.
Timeline for Underinsured Motorist Claims
Recovering compensation after an underinsured driver accident often takes longer than a standard claim. First, you must establish the at-fault driver’s liability and exhaust their coverage limits. Only then does your underinsured motorist coverage activate, beginning a second round of negotiations.
New York’s statute of limitations provides three years from the accident date to file lawsuits under CPLR Section 214. However, insurance policies contain shorter deadlines for providing notice and filing claims. Missing any deadline might eliminate valuable coverage sources.
Settling vs. Litigating an Underinsured Motorist Claim in New York
Most underinsured motorist claims settle without litigation, though the threat of arbitration or lawsuit strengthens negotiating positions. Insurance policies typically require arbitration rather than court trials for UIM disputes. Arbitration usually moves faster than a court case but still requires thorough preparation and persuasive presentation.
Cases involving multiple insurance companies and coverage disputes may require litigation to resolve. Brooklyn Supreme Court and Nassau County Supreme Court handle these complex insurance coverage cases. The litigation process adds time but may substantially increase recovery amounts.
How Finz & Finz Maximizes Recovery from Underinsured Driver Accidents
Finz & Finz has spent over four decades navigating complex insurance coverage issues for accident victims throughout New York and Long Island.
Our team includes former New York State Supreme Court Justices who understand how insurance companies minimize payouts when their insured drivers cause catastrophic injuries. We’ve recovered over $1 billion for clients by identifying every available insurance source and fighting for maximum compensation from each one.
Our car accident attorneys investigate beyond the obvious insurance policies to uncover additional coverage sources. We examine umbrella policies, commercial coverage for vehicles used for business, and household policies that might provide supplemental benefits.
This comprehensive approach has yielded substantial recoveries for clients from Brooklyn to Mineola whose initial outlook seemed bleak due to inadequate primary coverage.
Aggressive Negotiation with Multiple Insurers
Insurance companies protect their profits by denying or minimizing underinsured motorist claims through various tactics. They dispute injury severity, challenge medical treatment necessity, and argue that their insured’s coverage adequately compensates your losses.
Our attorneys counter these strategies with medical evidence, economic analysis, and aggressive negotiation that forces fair settlements.
We coordinate claims across multiple insurance carriers while protecting your rights under each policy. Your own insurance company becomes an adversary when you file an underinsured motorist claim, fighting against their own policyholder.
Having experienced legal representation levels the playing field against insurance companies that prioritize shareholders over injured policyholders.
FAQs for Car Accident Attorneys
What if the at-fault driver has no insurance at all?
Uninsured motorist coverage from your policy provides compensation when the at-fault driver lacks any insurance. This coverage functions similarly to underinsured coverage but doesn’t require exhausting non-existent coverage first. The Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation provides limited benefits if you lack uninsured motorist coverage.
How much underinsured motorist coverage do I need?
Coverage needs depend on your assets, income, and risk tolerance for catastrophic losses. Minimum coverage rarely provides adequate protection given modern medical costs. Consider purchasing coverage at least matching your liability limits, with higher amounts providing better protection.
Will using my underinsured coverage raise my rates?
Filing an underinsured motorist claim shouldn’t increase your premiums since you weren’t at fault. However, insurance companies may still raise rates citing general risk factors. Document the at-fault driver’s responsibility to contest any premium increases.
What if multiple family members were injured?
Each injured person may file separate claims up to per-person policy limits. Per-accident limits cap total payouts regardless of victim numbers. Coordinating multiple claims requires careful strategy to maximize each person’s recovery.
Do I need a car accident attorney for an underinsured motorist claim?
Legal representation significantly increases recovery amounts and claim success rates. Insurance companies offer unrepresented victims far less than fair value. Attorneys understand coverage nuances, negotiate effectively, and take cases to arbitration when necessary.
Take Legal Action to Protect Your Financial Future After an Underinsured Driver Accident
Stuart L. Finz, Brooklyn Car Accident Lawyer
Insurance companies have teams of adjusters and lawyers working to minimize your underinsured motorist claim. Each day without representation increases the risk of losing evidence and missing important deadlines.
At Finz & Finz, P.C., our experienced personal injury lawyer have the knowledge and resources needed to identify every available source of insurance coverage and pursue the full compensation you deserve. Your injuries, medical expenses, and financial challenges require immediate action to secure fair recovery beyond the at-fault driver’s limited coverage.
Do not let inadequate insurance coverage leave you responsible for someone else’s negligence. Contact 855-TOP-FIRM today to speak with a car accident attorney who has helped countless accident victims obtain justice.
- About the Author
- Latest Posts
Finz & Finz, P.C. is a New York and Long Island personal injury law firm based out of Mineola, NY. It was founded in 1984 and is highly rated, with many honors and awards of excellence.
