How New York Dog Bite Laws Changed in 2025
New York’s approach to dog bite liability changed significantly in April 2025, when the Court of Appeals decided Flanders v. Goodfellow. The ruling overturned nearly 20 years of precedent that had barred victims from bringing ordinary negligence claims against dog owners. As a result, dog bite victims in Brooklyn now have two separate legal paths for pursuing compensation.
Strict Liability for Known Dangerous Dogs
Under New York Agriculture and Markets Law Section 123, owners of dogs previously declared dangerous face strict liability for medical costs if their animal injures someone. This means a victim does not need to prove the owner acted carelessly.
The owner may be held strictly liable for medical expenses once a dangerous dog classification exists. Strict liability applies when an owner knew or should have known about a dog’s vicious propensities, although recovery is generally limited to medical expenses.
Evidence of prior aggressive behavior matters here. Growling, lunging, snapping at visitors, or slamming against windows when strangers approach may be considered by courts, along with other evidence, in determining whether an owner had reason to anticipate an attack.
Negligence Claims Now Available to Dog Bite Victims
Before Flanders, New York courts barred negligence lawsuits against dog owners under the 2006 Bard v. Jahnke decision. That rule created an unfair burden on victims who had to prove the owner knew their dog was dangerous, which was often impossible for first-time attacks.
The Court of Appeals recognized this injustice and reversed course. Brooklyn dog bite victims may now argue that an owner failed to exercise reasonable care, even if the dog had never previously bitten anyone. A dog that escapes through an unsecured gate, runs at visitors through an open door, or is walked without a leash in a crowded area may support a negligence claim.
This dual framework gives Brooklyn residents meaningful options. Many Brooklyn dog bite cases involve both strict liability and negligence arguments, allowing juries to consider multiple theories when determining fault.
Common Injuries a Brooklyn Dog Bite Lawyer Handles
Dog bites range from minor nips to life-threatening maulings. The physical harm depends on factors like the size of the dog, the location of the bite, and how quickly the victim receives medical care. Brooklyn emergency rooms treat thousands of dog bite injuries each year, and many require extensive follow-up treatment.
Severe attacks often cause damage that extends well beyond the initial wound. A Brooklyn dog bite lawyer at our firm regularly handles cases involving:
- Deep puncture wounds that damage underlying muscle, tendons, or nerves
- Crush injuries from powerful jaw pressure, particularly in attacks involving larger breeds
- Facial scarring and disfigurement that may require plastic surgery or reconstructive procedures
- Infections, including serious bacterial conditions that develop when wounds go untreated
- Psychological trauma, including post-traumatic stress, anxiety around animals, and depression
Children face particular risks in dog attacks. Their smaller stature places their faces and necks within easy reach of many dogs, and injuries to these areas may result in permanent disfigurement. Elderly Brooklyn residents are also vulnerable, as their thinner skin tears more easily and their immune systems may struggle to fight infections.
Where Dog Attacks Commonly Occur in Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s dense urban environment creates countless opportunities for interactions between people and dogs. Some settings present higher risks than others, and understanding where attacks commonly occur helps establish how liability may apply in your Brooklyn dog bite case.
Parks and Off-Leash Areas
Prospect Park, Fort Greene Park, and McCarren Park draw dog owners from across Brooklyn. While designated dog runs provide space for animals to exercise, conflicts arise when owners fail to supervise their pets or allow aggressive dogs to interact with others. Attacks at dog parks often involve multiple witnesses whose testimony may prove valuable in establishing how the incident unfolded.
Apartment Buildings and Common Areas
Brooklyn’s many apartment complexes, co-ops, and condos present unique liability questions. A dog that attacks in a hallway, elevator, lobby, or stairwell raises questions about both owner negligence and landlord responsibility. Building management companies that allow known aggressive dogs to remain on the property may face claims when those animals injure residents or visitors.
Sidewalks and Public Streets
Walking through Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO, Williamsburg, or any other neighborhood means sharing sidewalks with dog walkers. An owner who loses control of their leash or walks a large dog without adequate restraint may bear responsibility when their animal lunges at a pedestrian. Professional dog walkers who handle multiple animals at once face heightened duties to prevent attacks.
Private Homes in Brooklyn
Many Brooklyn dog bites occur during visits to friends, family, or neighbors. A guest attacked by a host’s dog may pursue a claim against the homeowner’s or renter’s insurance policy. The same principles apply to delivery workers, contractors, and others who enter residential properties for business purposes.
Compensation Available in Brooklyn Dog Bite Cases
New York law allows dog bite victims to recover compensation for multiple categories of harm. The specific damages available depend on the circumstances of the attack and the extent of your injuries. A Brooklyn dog bite lawyer evaluates each case individually to identify all potential sources of recovery.
Recoverable Economic Damages in Brooklyn Dog Bite Lawsuits
These cover the measurable financial losses resulting from a dog attack. Economic damages in Brooklyn dog bite claims typically include:
- Emergency room treatment, hospitalization, and ambulance transportation
- Follow-up care with specialists, physical therapists, and rehabilitation providers
- Prescription medications and medical equipment needed during recovery
- Lost wages during recovery, including sick days, vacation time, or unpaid leave
- Reduced earning capacity if permanent injuries affect your ability to work
Pain and Suffering Damages in Brooklyn Dog Bite Cases
Courts also recognize that dog bite injuries cause harm that goes beyond medical bills. Pain and suffering damages compensate for physical discomfort, emotional distress, anxiety, and the loss of enjoyment of life that follows a traumatic attack. Brooklyn juries may award substantial amounts in cases involving permanent scarring, disfigurement, or ongoing psychological effects.
Brooklyn Dog Bite Claims Involving Children
When a child suffers a dog bite in Brooklyn, parents typically file a claim on the child’s behalf. Compensation may address both current medical needs and anticipated future treatment, including plastic surgery to address scarring as the child grows. Courts take a long view in these cases, recognizing that injuries sustained in childhood may affect someone for decades.
FAQs for Brooklyn Dog Bite Lawyers
How long do I have to file a dog bite lawsuit in Brooklyn?
New York’s statute of limitations gives you three years from the date of the attack to file a personal injury lawsuit. However, claims against New York City or other government entities require filing a notice of claim within 90 days. Acting quickly also helps preserve evidence and witness memories, so consulting a Brooklyn dog bite lawyer soon after an attack is advisable.
Do I have a case if the dog had never bitten anyone before?
Yes. Following the April 2025 Flanders v. Goodfellow ruling, Brooklyn dog bite victims may pursue negligence claims even when the dog has no prior bite history. You may argue that the owner failed to use reasonable care by not properly securing or controlling their animal. Additionally, strict liability may apply if other evidence shows the owner knew or should have known about the dog’s aggressive tendencies.
What happens if I was bitten on someone else’s property in Brooklyn?
Property owners and renters in Brooklyn may be held liable for attacks that occur on their premises. If you were lawfully visiting a home, apartment, or business when a dog attacked you, the property owner’s or tenant’s insurance policy may cover your damages. Landlords may also face liability if they knew about a dangerous dog in their building.
What compensation might be available for my Brooklyn dog bite injuries?
Compensation varies based on injury severity but may include payment for medical expenses, lost wages, future treatment costs, pain and suffering, and damages related to scarring or disfigurement. Children attacked by dogs may also recover for anticipated future medical needs. A Brooklyn dog bite lawyer evaluates your specific situation to identify all applicable categories of damages.
What if the dog owner claims I provoked the attack?
Provocation is a defense dog owners sometimes raise. Under New York law, an owner’s liability may be reduced or eliminated if the victim tormented, abused, or physically threatened the dog. However, actions like approaching a dog calmly, walking near its property, or simply being present in a public place do not constitute provocation. A Brooklyn dog bite attorney investigates the facts and counters false provocation claims.
Contact a Brooklyn Dog Bite Lawyer at Finz & Finz Today
After a dog attack, your focus should be on medical care and recovery, not insurance disputes or legal research. Waiting too long to take action can limit your legal options.
At Finz & Finz, P.C., our Brooklyn dog bite lawyers handle your claim from start to finish. We investigate the incident, identify responsible parties, negotiate with insurance companies, and take cases to trial when necessary, allowing you to concentrate on healing.
New York law now provides broader protections for dog bite victims, including expanded recovery options following the Flanders decision. Our legal team is prepared to pursue all available claims on your behalf.
Contact Finz & Finz, P.C. today for a free consultation. With offices in Manhattan and Mineola, we represent clients throughout Brooklyn. Call now to speak with a Brooklyn dog bite lawyer about your case.
More
